Michigan HOA Election Rules

Michigan HOA election rules can vary significantly depending on how the homeowner association is legally organized and what its governing documents require. Unlike some states, Michigan does not have one comprehensive statute containing election procedures for every traditional homeowner association. Many Michigan HOAs are organized as nonprofit corporations, making the Michigan Nonprofit Corporation Act, the association’s articles and bylaws, and applicable governing documents important sources for determining how board elections must be conducted. Michigan condominium associations also have additional requirements under the Michigan Condominium Act.

If you are trying to determine whether an HOA election was properly conducted, start with the association’s bylaws. The bylaws generally identify who may vote, how directors are elected, the number of directors, terms of office, meeting and notice procedures, quorum requirements, and whether proxies, ballots, or electronic voting are permitted.

Direct Answer: Michigan HOA elections are generally governed by the association’s bylaws and applicable Michigan corporate or condominium law. For nonprofit HOAs, state law permits several voting methods, including in-person voting, proxies, and certain ballot procedures when authorized by the governing documents. Condominium associations may also be subject to specific election and developer-transition requirements under Michigan’s Condominium Act.

Definition: What has the Michigan HOA Election Rules?

Michigan HOA election rules are the legal and governing-document requirements that determine how homeowners vote for association directors and how an HOA conducts its membership elections. These rules may come from Michigan statutes, the HOA’s articles of incorporation, bylaws, recorded covenants, master deed, resolutions, and other applicable governing documents.

The first question is therefore not simply, “What does Michigan law say?” It is “What type of association is this, and which governing documents and statutes apply to it?”

Does Michigan Have a Specific HOA Election Law?

Not for every traditional homeowner association.

Michigan’s corporate statutes include the Nonprofit Corporation Act, and Michigan’s Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs explains that corporate governance is determined by applicable law as well as the corporation’s articles, bylaws, and decisions of its members or shareholders.

This matter because many community associations are structured as nonprofit corporations. In those cases, the association’s bylaws can establish important election procedures within the framework allowed by Michigan law.

For condominium communities, the analysis is different. The Michigan Condominium Act requires condominium projects to have bylaws governing administration, and those bylaws are recorded as part of the master deed or otherwise provided through the master deed.

Traditional HOA vs. Condominium Association

IssueTraditional Michigan HOAMichigan Condominium Association
Primary governance documentsArticles, bylaws, covenants and rulesMaster deed, bylaws and condominium documents
Corporate lawMay apply if organized as a corporationMay apply depending on organizational structure
Condominium ActGenerally not applicable simply because an association is called an HOASpecifically applicable
Board electionsPrimarily governed by applicable law and bylawsGoverned by applicable law plus condominium documents
Developer transition rulesDepends on governing structure and documentsSpecific statutory provisions may apply
Voting proceduresCheck bylaws and applicable statuteCheck bylaws, master deed and Condominium Act

The name “HOA” alone does not determine the legal rules. A homeowner should identify the association’s legal structure before challenging or evaluating an election.

Who Can Vote in a Michigan HOA Election?

The people entitled to vote are generally determined by the association’s governing documents and applicable law.

For a nonprofit corporation organized on a membership basis, Michigan law defines a member as a person holding membership according to the corporation’s articles or bylaws.

That means ownership of a home and membership in the association often go together, but the exact voting rights should be confirmed in the governing documents.

A Michigan HOA should review:

  1. The articles of incorporation.
  2. The current bylaws.
  3. Recorded covenants or declaration.
  4. Any applicable amendments.
  5. The association’s membership records.
  6. Provisions governing voting rights and assessments.
  7. Any special classes of membership.

Can an HOA Restrict a Homeowner from Voting?

A voting restriction should have a legal or governing-document basis. The association should not simply invent eligibility requirements for an election after the voting process has begun.

For example, if the bylaws establish who is entitled to vote, the board should apply those provisions consistently to similarly situated members.

Where eligibility is disputed, the association should document the basis for its determination and preserve the relevant membership and election records.

How Are HOA Board Directors Elected in Michigan?

For Michigan nonprofit corporations, the governing documents can establish how directors are elected, subject to applicable statutory requirements.

Michigan’s Nonprofit Corporation Act provides that, unless otherwise provided by the articles, directors are generally elected by a plurality of the votes cast at an election.

A plurality means that the candidate receiving more votes than any other candidate wins the available seat; it does not necessarily mean that the candidate must receive more than 50% of all eligible membership votes.

However, an HOA’s governing documents can establish different procedures where permitted by law. Therefore, homeowners should not assume that every Michigan HOA election automatically follows the same voting formula.

What Is Cumulative Voting?

Michigan law also permits certain corporations to provide for cumulative voting in director elections through their articles or bylaws. Under cumulative voting, voting power can be allocated among candidates according to the rules established in the governing documents.

Because cumulative voting can materially change election results, homeowners should check the bylaws before assuming that each voter simply casts one vote for each available director seat.

Can Michigan HOA Elections Be Held by Ballot?

Yes, in circumstances authorized by the association’s governing documents and Michigan law.

Michigan’s Nonprofit Corporation Act allows a corporation to provide in its articles or bylaws that members may take certain actions without a meeting, including the election of directors, through ballots.

The statute establishes requirements for such ballots. Among other things, the ballot must identify the proposed action, provide an opportunity to vote for or against each proposed action, and specify a deadline for returning the ballot.

For ballot-based corporate action under this provision, the statutory deadline must generally be at least 20 days and no more than 90 days after the corporation provides the ballot.

This is different from simply sending homeowners an informal email asking them to vote. The association needs to follow the applicable authorization and procedure.

Can Michigan HOA Members Vote by Proxy?

Proxy voting may be available, but the governing documents and applicable law matter.

Michigan’s Nonprofit Corporation Act generally permits a shareholder or member entitled to vote to authorize another person to act by proxy unless the applicable statute, articles, or bylaws provide otherwise.

An HOA should therefore establish clear procedures for:

  • Who may hold a proxy?
  • Whether proxies must be written.
  • When proxies expire.
  • Whether a proxy is revocable.
  • Whether a proxy can be used specifically for director elections.
  • Whether the bylaws impose additional requirements.

A proxy should not be treated as an unlimited authorization unless the governing documents actually provide for that type of authority.

Can Michigan HOAs Use Electronic Voting?

Electronic voting may be available when properly authorized.

Michigan’s corporate law was amended to permit electronic transactions and communications, and Michigan’s Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs explains that nonprofit corporations can provide for voting by electronic transmission in their governing documents.

The association should therefore distinguish between:

Electronic voting authorized by governing documents
and
an informal online poll created by the board.

Those are not necessarily the same thing.

Before relying on an online voting platform, an HOA should verify that its articles, bylaws, and applicable law permit the proposed method and that the association has appropriate procedures for verifying voter eligibility and preserving election records.

What Is the Quorum Requirement for a Michigan HOA Election?

A quorum is the minimum level of participation required before members can conduct certain business at a meeting.

The exact quorum requirement for an HOA election should be taken from the applicable bylaws and statute.

This is particularly important because quorum and the number of votes required to elect directors are separate concepts.

For example:

  • Quorum: Determines whether enough eligible members are represented to conduct the meeting or action.
  • Votes for election: Determines how candidates are selected under the applicable election rule.
  • Majority: Generally, means more than half of the relevant votes under the applicable rule.
  • Plurality: Means receiving more votes than another candidate or candidates.

Michigan’s Nonprofit Corporation Act contains specific rules concerning membership voting and director elections, but an HOA’s governing documents may establish additional requirements where permitted.

What Happens When an HOA Board Election Is Contested?

A disputed election should be analyzed by working backward through the election procedure.

Step 1: Obtain the governing documents

Get the current:

  • Bylaws
  • Articles of incorporation
  • Declaration or covenants
  • Amendments
  • Election rules or resolutions
  • Relevant meeting notices

Step 2: Determine voter eligibility

Identify which members were entitled to vote on the election date.

Step 3: Review the notice

Compare the actual election notice with the notice requirements contained in the bylaws and applicable law.

Step 4: Review the voting method

Determine whether the election used:

  • In-person ballots
  • Written ballots
  • Proxies
  • Mail voting
  • Electronic voting
  • Another method authorized by the governing documents

Step 5: Verify the vote count

Review the number of eligible voters, ballots received, challenged ballots, proxies, abstentions, and votes attributed to each candidate.

Step 6: Check the election record

Michigan’s Nonprofit Corporation Act provides for inspectors in certain circumstances. Inspectors can address matters such as voting eligibility, quorum, proxies, ballots, challenges, counting and tabulation.

Step 7: Follow the association’s dispute procedure

Many associations have internal procedures for complaints or disputes. Those procedures should be reviewed before escalating the matter.

For significant disputes involving director removal, election validity, corporate authority, or potential litigation, obtaining advice from a Michigan attorney familiar with community-association law may be appropriate.

What has the Common Michigan HOA Election Problems?

Election disputes frequently arise from procedure rather than from the actual vote count.

Common issues to investigate include:

1. Incorrect Notice

Members may challenge an election when the association did not follow the required notice period or delivery method.

2. Unclear Voter Eligibility

A dispute can arise when the association cannot clearly determine which members are entitled to vote.

3. Improper Proxy Forms

A proxy may be challenged if it does not comply with the bylaws or applicable statutory requirements.

4. Unauthorized Electronic Voting

An association should verify that electronic voting is actually authorized rather than assuming that an online poll is automatically valid.

5. Incorrect Quorum Calculation

Counting ineligible members or improperly submitted proxies can affect whether quorum was achieved.

6. Ballot-Counting Disputes

Election procedures should identify how questionable, duplicate, incomplete, or late ballots are handled.

7. Failure to Follow the Bylaws

Even when a board believes an alternative procedure is more convenient, the association should follow its governing documents unless they are properly amended or another lawful procedure applies.

Do Michigan Condominium Associations Have Different Election Rules?

Yes.

This distinction is particularly important for Michigan homeowners searching for “HOA election rules” when their community is legally a condominium.

The Michigan Condominium Act contains specific provisions governing condominium administration and developer transition. For example, during developer-controlled periods, the Act establishes stages at which non-developer co-owners obtain rights to elect portions of the association’s board.

Under the statute, specific election rights are triggered as certain percentages of units are conveyed to non-developer co-owners. The law includes thresholds involving 25%, 50%, and 75% of the units that may be created, with additional rules governing the transition of board control.

This is one reason homeowners should identify whether their community is a condominium project before applying general HOA election advice.

Can Homeowners Remove an HOA Director in Michigan?

Potentially, yes, but the applicable procedure matters.

For Michigan nonprofit corporations organized on a stock or membership basis, the Nonprofit Corporation Act provides that members may remove one or more directors with or without cause unless the articles provide that directors may be removed only for cause. The statute also provides a voting requirement for removal, subject to permitted variations in the governing documents.

The precise procedure should therefore be determined by reviewing the association’s:

  • Articles
  • Bylaws
  • Director terms
  • Membership voting provisions
  • Meeting requirements
  • Notice requirements
  • Removal provisions

A petition or informal homeowner vote does not necessarily remove a director simply because a number of residents support it.

Michigan HOA Election Checklist

Before conducting an HOA board election, the association should verify the following:

Election ItemWhat to Verify
Governing documentsCurrent bylaws and amendments
Voter eligibilityMembers entitled to vote
NoticeRequired timing and delivery method
CandidatesEligibility and nomination requirements
Voting methodMeeting, ballot, proxy or electronic method
QuorumApplicable quorum threshold
Vote calculationPlurality, majority or other rule
ProxiesForm, authorization and validity
BallotsDeadline and handling procedures
InspectorsWhether inspectors are required or requested
RecordsBallots, proxies, minutes and results
ResultsAccurate tabulation and certification

This checklist is a practical starting point, not a substitute for reviewing the specific documents governing the community.

What Documents Should Homeowners Request After an HOA Election?

A homeowner investigating an election should consider requesting documents relevant to the voting process, subject to the association’s document-access rules.

Useful records may include:

  1. Election notice.
  2. Current bylaws.
  3. Election rules.
  4. Candidate information.
  5. Proxy forms.
  6. Ballot forms.
  7. Voting instructions.
  8. Meeting minutes.
  9. Election results.
  10. Relevant membership voting records.
  11. Inspector’s report, if inspectors were used.
  12. Board resolutions concerning the election.

The goal is to establish what rule applied, how the election was conducted, and whether the recorded result matches the applicable procedure.

Michigan HOA Election Rules: Key Takeaways

Michigan HOA elections are not governed by one universal election procedure applicable to every homeowner association. The correct analysis depends on the association’s legal structure and governing documents.

For nonprofit HOAs, Michigan’s Nonprofit Corporation Act provides a framework for member voting, director elections, proxies, ballots and other corporate procedures.

For condominium communities, the Michigan Condominium Act adds another layer of requirements, including statutory rules concerning condominium bylaws and developer-to-owner board control transitions.

The safest practical approach is to identify the association’s governing documents first, determine the applicable Michigan statute second, and then compare the actual election procedure against those requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions About Michigan HOA Election Rules

What has the basic Michigan HOA election rules?

Michigan does not have one universal election procedure for every traditional HOA. Election procedures generally depend on the association’s legal structure, governing documents, and applicable Michigan law.

Can an HOA in Michigan vote by proxy?

Yes, proxy voting can be permitted for members of Michigan nonprofit corporations, subject to applicable statutory requirements and restrictions in the articles or bylaws. The HOA should follow its specific proxy provisions when conducting an election.

Can Michigan HOA elections be held electronically?

Electronic voting may be permitted when properly authorized by the association’s governing documents and applicable law. Michigan has statutory provisions allowing nonprofit corporations to provide for electronic voting and related electronic procedures.

Does an HOA election require a quorum in Michigan?

Whether quorum is required, and the applicable threshold, depends on the association’s governing documents and the applicable corporate statute. Homeowners should distinguish the quorum requirement from the number of votes needed to elect a director.

How are HOA directors elected in Michigan?

For Michigan nonprofit corporations, directors are generally elected according to the corporation’s governing documents and applicable statutory voting rules. Michigan law provides that, unless otherwise provided, directors are elected by a plurality of votes cast.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top